Brand extension right and left

Global SourcesUpdated on 2023/12/01

Hot Topics

Global Sources Exhibitions

At the beginning of 2004, when PepsiCo decided to use its famous beverage brand to fully enter the sportswear industry in China, it did not cause too many irresponsible remarks in the market. Most people feel that under the leadership of the "Pepsi" brand with "young" and "avant-garde" as its core values, Coke and T-shirts, which seem to be irrelevant, can be combined logically.

Interestingly, just two years ago, when PepsiCo's Chinese counterpart, Hangzhou Wahaha Group, announced its foray into the children's clothing industry, the brand extension strategy of the largest food and beverage group in China encountered various controversies. The sound continues to this day. The biggest question people ask about this local brand is, what is the core value of "Wahaha"? It is also the connection between beverages and clothing. What kind of connection can "Wahaha" provide?

In fact, it is not the first time for "Wahaha" to be questioned on the road of brand extension. As early as 1995, the brand's development from a children's drink to an adult drink was cited as its biggest adventure. At that time, some people predicted that Wahaha would fall because of the vagueness of the brand personality. In fact, it is precisely because of this extension that Hangzhou Wahaha Group has obtained the opportunity to accelerate its development. The sales scale has grown from 1 billion in 1996 to over 10 billion in 2003, which is regarded as a legend in the industry.

Because of this, when the children's clothing strategy was constantly being preached as a negative case, Zong Qinghou, the founder, chairman and general manager of the group who created the "Wahaha" legend, just laughed: "I doubt we There are always many people with ideas, but we have always done a good job."

Zong Qinghou has always been quite confident in his "savvy" in brand marketing, and the "Wahaha" brand is very popular in the food and beverage industry and the children's industry. The two directions of extension are also the foresight he set at the beginning of his business. With a solid foundation in the beverage market, Zong began to have the energy to pursue another of his ideals. Getting involved in children's clothing is his first step in this direction. "The cross-industry brand extension will bring us new growth opportunities." Zong Qinghou expects that "Wahaha" will be able to support a new "children's paradise" after becoming a "drink kingdom".

Start: Accumulate Brand Equity

The implementation of brand extension strategy can only be successful after certain accumulation of related brand equity such as popularity, reputation and loyalty. Of course, Wahaha is no exception, but because it seized the right opportunity, this initial accumulation process did not take too long.

The "Wahaha" brand was born in 198_9. Zong Qinghou carefully studied the market at that time and found that although there were many brands of nutritional liquids, none of them were aimed at the target consumer group of children. So he seized this market segment and developed a children's nutritional solution for "appetizers for children", which he named "Wahaha". At the same time, the company officially changed its name to Hangzhou Wahaha Nutritional Food Factory.

Because of that famous children's song, the name "Wahaha" is very friendly and easy to spread. With the strong advertising campaign, the catchy slogan "Drinking Wahaha, eating is fragrant" quickly spread in the streets, and the brand awareness was quickly established. "What's more important," Zong Qinghou emphasized, "it does have an effect after a child's drinking once or twice, so it has a reliable and genuine reputation. Everyone knows that Wahaha is not a hollow brand that only relies on advertising. "

The positive effect brought by the brand is immediate in performance indicators: in 1990, the sales of Wahaha's nutritional solution exceeded 100 million yuan, and in 1991 it rapidly increased to 400 million yuan. The continuous expansion of the sales scale is also the continuous tempering and testing of the brand. Zong Qinghou believes that "to ensure our credibility, we must first not be sloppy in product quality." In Zong's view, the brand equity accumulated by "Wahaha" at this time is equivalent to the credibility of the enterprise. Its core value recognized by consumers is not the childlikeness and vitality revealed by its literal meaning, but "nutrition and health" which are inseparable from product quality. In this regard, in the market environment where inferior products were flooded and companies changed frequently, it was indeed easier to win consumers' loyalty to brands and companies, and it also allowed Wahaha to find an entry point beyond a single product pattern.

Fruit milk, the second product Wahaha developed in 1992, is still aimed at children. At that time, Wahaha had just acquired an insolvent state-owned enterprise under the arrangement of the Hangzhou Municipal Government. According to Zong Qinghou, the original intention of developing new fruit milk products was only because "more than 2,000 employees were added all at once, and the production and sales of nutrient solution alone could not digest so many people".

Although there were many similar products on the market at that time, with Wahaha's brand influence, sales channels and advantages of large-scale production, fruit milk was quickly accepted by consumers after it was launched, and it once occupied half of the market. . The power of the brand turned the original state-owned enterprise, which was almost bankrupt, into profit within three months.

Judging from the functions and selling points of the product, fruit milk is actually similar to the original nutritional solution for children. Even the lyrics in the advertisement song "nutritious and delicious" are clearly connected. Therefore, Zong Qinghou does not regard it as a brand extension in the true sense, "but rather the expansion of the product line." But there is no doubt that the two main products launched in succession have won great success in the market. The success has consolidated Wahaha's brand advantage and laid a good foundation for future brand extension.

Left: Beverage Kingdom

Although Zong Qinghou believes that the Wahaha brand based on children's beverage products should have two potential brand extension directions - that is, to extend to other products in the children's industry , and extended to other beverage products. However, when looking for new development opportunities for Wahaha in 1995, Zong Qinghou chose the latter from the perspective of product relevance and full utilization of existing resources: "Whether it is production line, R&D strength, or sales network, our The strengths are more suitable for breakthroughs in the beverage industry, which is more relevant."

At present, Wahaha Group has five categories of dozens of products, including bottled water, carbonated drinks, juice drinks, dairy products, and eight-treasure porridge. The sales volume of water, milk yogurt and eight-treasure porridge has been ranked first in the country for many years. 6.6 billion total assets, 10 billion sales scale - become China's largest food and beverage company. In the growth process of "Beverage Kingdom", the brand extension strategy contributed a lot.

Children's products-adult products have greater market potential for adult beverages than the children's market. Wahaha's first product extended to adult beverages, selected pure water with the widest audience. It can be said that naming the pure water "Wahaha" is the biggest turning point in expanding from the field of children's beverages to the field of adult beverages, and it is also the most controversial. "Many people thought that Wahaha was taking a risk." Zong recalled that at that time, many people in China used the brand positioning theory to refute this practice, and suggested that Wahaha should adopt a multi-brand strategy for adult beverages. "They said that if we extend like this, the brand personality of Wahaha will become unclear, and it will affect the original advantages of the brand."

Zong Qinghou thought otherwise.

He believes that the advantages of multiple brands should not be denied, but this requires a huge investment in the first place. It is basically impossible to cultivate a new brand into a national famous brand comparable to Wahaha without spending 200 million in marketing and advertising a year. In the reality of limited funding sources, if you try to attack in all directions and divert your energy, even if the new brand succeeds, it may drag down the follow-up investment and cultivation of Wahaha brand.

In 1995, the market for popular beverages such as purified water was still developing, the competition was not fierce, and there was no monopoly brand. Generally speaking, it was still in a period of brand reshuffling. Therefore, the cost of using the brand extension strategy is the smallest, but the chance of success is very large. "For us, concentrating resources to build a big brand, the brand's high popularity, reputation, consumers' sense of trust and security can drive a series of products to sell well." Although Zong Qinghou himself is a "perceptual" "A well-known enterprise manager for decision-making, but Wahaha's brand extension is based on rational appeal. He pointed out that brand extension must first ensure that the quality of the product does not deviate from the product itself, and "explain to consumers what our purified water is and where the benefits are."

Zong Qinghou believes that there are several elements in the process of "Wahaha" breaking through into an adult brand to ensure the success of this extension: First, the core values of the Wahaha brand include "credibility and safety", etc. Quality assurance is compatible with purified water and adult products such as eight-treasure porridge and tea beverages to be launched in the future; second, the "Wahaha" brand has a relatively strong affinity, and the unique childlikeness of the name itself and concepts such as "joy and health" are often It will also gain the preference of adults, making them easy to accept; third, most of the markets that Wahaha chose to enter were not strong leading brands at that time, so there was a lot of potential space.

On the basis of these factors, Wahaha has also made comprehensive adjustments to its advertising strategy in order to match the new product target consumer groups. Efforts have been made to dilute the original concept of children in the promotion, and promote young and pure emotional songs such as "I only see you in my eyes" and "Love you is equal to loving yourself", which has successfully created adults, especially young people's sense of identity with the brand .

Product Brand-Corporate Brand With the gradual development of the scale of the enterprise, Wahaha Group is constantly seeking to enter more market segments and find new growth points of performance. As a product brand, "Wahaha" has a relatively single core value, and it is impossible to completely dominate all multi-level and personalized market segments.

In 1998, Wahaha Group set its sales target ten times that of 1996. It was also in this year that the group aimed at a new profit growth point and launched the carbonated beverage "Very Cola" series, which was intended to challenge the two giants of "Coca-Cola" and "Pepsi-Cola". Obviously, "Wahaha" is no longer enough to show its momentum and difference to be "the Chinese people's own cola" and to challenge the century-old brands "Kekou" and "Pepsi".

"To make Coke, we chose to create another brand because Chinese companies making Coke is a very important thing in itself and needs a particularly impactful name." Zong Qinghou believes that after ten years of development, the company It also has the comprehensive strength to create a brand new brand. The launch of the "very" brand has made up for some of the cultural connotations of "Wahaha" as a product brand. Among them, the elements of atmospheric fashion and superiority broaden the definition of the original brand. "The English name Future gives a hopeful concept, which means that our cola is the future cola." Zong Qinghou is obviously quite satisfied with the new brand, "very" is currently extended to a series of carbonated drinks, such as Very lemon, very sweet orange, etc., and Liangle's product lines "Sprite", "Fanta", "Seven Up", "Mirinda" and other comprehensive competition.

In the promotion of Very Cola, Zong Qinghou adopted a strategy of mutual penetration between brand extension and multi-brand strategy. With the dual-brand or joint-brand approach of "Wahaha · Very Cola", we hope to enhance the influence of the two brands at the same time. "This is not simply to use Wahaha as a brand extension, but to use it as a corporate brand identity to provide a guarantee for Very Cola." Zong pointed out that the brand awareness and reputation established by "Wahaha" ten years of local development, not only can Enhance consumers' trust in the quality of Very Cola, and it is even more beneficial in attracting distributors and expanding distribution channels. Because of avoiding large and medium-sized cities where Liangle has an absolute advantage in promotion, and switching to the "rural route", by 2003, the annual production and sales volume of Very Cola has exceeded 600,000 tons, which is close to Pepsi, which sells 1 million tons in China. .

After this, Wahaha Group continued to adopt this co-branding approach to launch other series such as "Wahaha · Very Tea Drink", "Wahaha · Active Sports Drink" and so on. It has successfully transformed "Wahaha" from an original product brand to a corporate brand with a wider range of radiation. In this way, on the one hand, various beverages maintain an overall image in the market, and on the other hand, they lock in corresponding consumer groups.

"Enterprise brand and product brand are like the relationship between mother and child." Zong Qinghou believes that enterprise brand grasps the credibility of communication from a macro perspective, is abstract and general, and has inclusive power; while product brand is concrete and vivid, can Timely adjustments based on consumer preferences and market changes. This pattern can avoid the risks of "over-exploitation of brand resources" and "ambiguous brand positioning" that may be brought about by brand extension.

Go Right: Children's Paradise

After fifteen years of development in the beverage industry, Wahaha Group has accumulated more and more capital. According to Zong Qinghou, Wahaha, with total assets of more than 6 billion yuan, not only has no bank loans of a penny, but also has nearly 2 billion spare funds in the bank. The next five years are the five years that Wahaha plans to vigorously expand, and the business scale is expected to triple. However, the demand for the main traditional beverage industry has not grown so fast, and the entire domestic market has almost entered a state of saturation. Therefore, Wahaha must choose to find another way in other industries.

Wahaha once stood at a fork in the road of brand extension, and it chose one of the paths to go down. And now, it's back to where it started, and it's off again. So can it reach the ideal "children's paradise"? Children's clothing was the first pathfinder stone that Zong Qinghou found. In 2002, Wahaha decided to enter the children's clothing industry, and proposed to be "the first children's clothing brand in the country".

According to data provided by Wahaha, there are 287 million children aged 0-14 in China, accounting for 22.5% of the total population. At present, the annual output of children's clothing in the country is only more than 600 million pieces, with an average of less than 3 pieces per child per year, and there is no national children's clothing brand. This huge market potential is in line with Wahaha's principle of choosing the direction of brand extension.

According to Zong Qinghou, the "Wahaha" brand still has a very strong influence in the children's market. To use it to develop the children's clothing industry is to use the brand's recognition in the minds of children to gain a share of the children's clothing market. "From children's nutrient solution to fruit milk, AD calcium milk, Wahaha has been accompanying children's growth, it means joy and health." Zong thinks.

External doubts But this seemingly logical brand extension has been questioned by the outside world. Zeng Zhaohui, who has been engaged in brand strategy research for many years, pointed out that although Wahaha started with children's beverages, it has always been inclined to adultization in the development of more than ten years. In order to cooperate with the marketing of pure water and very cola, Wahaha has also become farther and farther away from the positioning of children in the way of advertising. "For more than ten years, what else has Wahaha let children remember except one or two commercial songs from the early days?"

Most of the opponents believe that today's "Wahaha" is no longer It's like a children's brand. Now that Wahaha has returned to the starting point and continues to expand in the children's industry, the brand bond it needs is precisely the "childlikeness" that it has tried to downplay in the past. The core value of the brand established by Wahaha in the beverage industry is consistent with its professional status in this industry. Consumers' perception of Wahaha is that it is a very powerful beverage leading enterprise. Its brand advantage lies in its high-quality products, perfect services and huge marketing network accumulated over the years. And these are closely linked to the beverage industry. Entering the children's clothing industry, not only the advantageous resources cannot be shared, but may cause confusion in management.

"From this point of view, Wahaha children's clothing and other brands of children's clothing are standing on the same starting line, and there is no advantage at all." Zeng Zhaohui, for example, among children's clothing brands that have entered the Chinese market, such as Mickey Mouse, Snoopy, Maruko, etc., all first paved the way for the brand through cartoon culture, and then launched clothing. Focus on the building of brand culture, it is easier to get the favor of children.

Zong Qinghou did not take it seriously in the face of the outside world's claim that Wahaha's core values cannot cross age and industry boundaries at the same time. He believes that the "Wahaha" brand is inherently "happy and childlike" even if it has not been advertised. "This kind of association is a rare link for cross-industry brand extension." On the other hand, in the positioning of children's clothing, Wahaha emphasizes that it is "green children's clothing" that is "healthy, comfortable and beautiful", "high-end quality, medium Low-end price", and strive to be consistent with the original brand positioning in terms of quality and price. However, Zong Qinghou also said frankly: "When we make children's clothing, we cross the river by feeling the stones, and finally let the market speak and let the consumers speak."

Wahaha's idea of operating children's clothing is mainly to produce by OEM, and to open franchise stores nationwide with zero franchise fee. The group itself cooperates with professional children's clothing design units, and is responsible for brand promotion and style design. "In terms of channel establishment, although the sales channels of beverages cannot be shared with children's clothing, the original brand advantage is very helpful." Zong Qinghou said that the investment promotion activities for children's clothing have not yet officially started, and there are more than 2,000 distributors. Take the initiative to come to contact. The sales network of Wahaha children's clothing was quickly established with the help of the original beverage distributor resources. "It not only reduces the cost of expansion, but also shortens the time to enter the market."

On the other hand, Wahaha takes advantage of the complementary advantages of children's products and promotes positive interaction between children's clothing and beverages through various promotional activities. For example, AD Calcium Milk's "replacing children's clothes with cards" has achieved good results, not only greatly improving the popularity of Wahaha's children's clothing, but also driving the sales of AD calcium milk to a certain extent.

After more than a year of careful development, Wahaha has opened more than 800 specialty stores across the country, which is not a small gap from the 2,000 originally envisaged by Zong Qinghou. The important reason for this adjustment is that Wahaha Group's channel network has been strong in the vast rural market for many years, and the market influence of its main products such as "Wahaha Pure Water" and "Very Cola" are also concentrated in rural areas and small and medium-sized cities. , and the acceptance of brand children's clothing in these markets is obviously not high. According to some children's clothing store operators: in terms of styles, there is little difference between Wahaha and the children's clothing produced by small enterprises in Jiangsu and Zhejiang; although the fabrics and quality are relatively good, "the children's clothes can be worn for one season". Unwilling to pay this part of the price difference brought by the brand.

In response to this situation, Zong Qinghou slowed down the expansion of children's clothing. Do not seek to enlarge the volume, but develop cautiously, and stabilize the brand reputation of children's clothing first. "Most of the existing 800 specialty stores are concentrated in prefecture-level cities. If we want to open 2,000 stores, it means that 75% of China's more than 2,000 counties will enter. The current consumption level has not yet reached." Zong Qinghou analyzed.

Despite this, Zong Qinghou is satisfied that the children's clothing industry can bring in 200 million sales revenue a year: "Children's clothing did not meet the original expected plan, it is an underestimation of the overall market demand, not the brand's Influence is not enough." But obviously, Zong Qinghou, who has always emphasized that "if you don't do it, do it best", is more careful about the next step of brand extension in the children's industry.

Source the latest products from verified suppliers on our global sourcing platform, or install our app. Subscribe to our magazines for more in-depth insights and product discovery.

More Sourcing News

Previous Article